The Knife of Never Letting Go by Patrick Ness

Reviewed by Hope M.
Grade 11

The Knife of Letting Go takes place on the planet New World, which became inhabited by human settlers twenty-three years before the start of the novel. Todd Hewitt lives in Prentisstown, where he was taught that the native creatures of New World, the Spackle, released a disease onto the colonizers. This germ, called Noise, causes every individual to hear everybody else’s thoughts in words, pictures, colors, and sounds. Additionally, according to those in Prentisstown, all the women were killed by the illness. However, as Todd is nearing the day he finally becomes a man, he discovers a break from the relentless sounds. Upon finding this, the men who have taken care of Todd since his mother’s death tell Todd he must escape Prentisstown. When Todd realizes the source of the silence is a girl named Viola, he embarks on a long journey with many unanswered questions. Along the way, he finds that Prentisstown has an evil, twisted history, and somehow he is supposed to play a role in the town’s villainous plot.

I thought it was a fairly good book. The plot was definitely interesting, despite being predictable at some parts. The protagonists, Todd and Viola, were well-developed characters, and their dilemmas allow the reader to root for and empathize with them. As for the author’s style of writing, I think he overused certain writing techniques. While I’m sure he did so to emphasize moments of conflict, I personally felt his use of run-on sentences was excessive, distracting me from what was occurring in the story.

Regardless, I still enjoyed the book. Patrick Ness portrays a lesson of remembering who you are even when you’re surrounded by chaos, and I think that’s an important message. While there were aspects of the writing that I didn’t like, it’s certainly still good enough that I want to proceed with the series. For these reasons, I would recommend The Knife of Letting Go to anyone who enjoys dystopian novels with plenty of action and suspense. 

WIN A FREE COPY OF CHAOS WALKING: THE KNIFE OF NEVER LETTING GO! 
Stop by the Winter Park Library in the Teen Area, and fill out an entry form for your chance to win. CHAOS WALKING, starring Tom Holland and Daisy Ridley, is currently in theaters!

Kingdom of the Wicked by Kerri Maniscalco

Reviewed by Isabella T.
Grade 9

You always have the power of choice, even when those choices seem limited.

Never forget that.

What would you choose? Team up with a Prince of Hell to avenge your sister, or leave the stones unturned and spent the rest of your days wondering what happened? This clever and brave witch doesn’t have the luxury of asking the difficult questions that could put her family at risk. But when she meets Wrath, a magnetic Prince of Hell who seems to have all the answers; she might just have a way to solve her sister’s murder and save the witches from the perpetrator.

Kerri Maniscalco’s Kingdom of the Wicked follows witch Emilia DiCarlo and her family. The Dicarlo family comes from a long line of witches. Her nonna, mother, and twin sister Vittoria are all witches. Emilia and Vittoria grew up hearing stories about The Wicked from their nonna, always warning them that they should stay as far away from them as possible. Vittoria was the opposite of Emilia, always on a mission and chasing adventures. Emilia loved to read and cook. When Vittoria didn’t show up for dinner one night at her family’s restaurant, Emilia worries that something might have happened to her. Emilia vowed that she wouldn’t rest when her body is found, until she apprehended her beloved sister’s killer. Emilia didn’t know that a series of murders have been occurring in Sicily, and all happened to be witches. Wrath is tasked with finding the killer, and when Emilia realizes they have the same goals, a partnership between them might get them both what they wanted. But is Wrath really on her side?

One of my favorite things about this book is that Maniscalco managed to include essential Italian cultural factors. Whenever we read a book that is settled in a place where we are unfamiliar with its culture, I think the author must provide the reader with background information. Simple things like going to the market, or specific words in Italian, and the recipes she cooked, and the dynamic with her family at their restaurant gave me a better understanding of the main character’s life. It is also one reason many people read and learn about different cultures, and it is significant that even though fantasy or fiction books, we can still learn about things like that. Another point of interest in this book is character growth. I am a firm believer that a great book has at least one dynamic character. That means that the character undergoes a change, specifically growth, or manages to conquer their main issue. Even though a character coming out of their comfort zone is a popular trope, it can significantly enhance the plot when executed well. As Emilia embarks on this adventure, she tries to be more like her departed sister and take risks. Risks are a big part of achieving her goal. Her power and the need for vengeance create the perfect equation for finally becoming the best version of herself. One that can help her avenge her sister.

Readers who enjoy supernatural creatures, enemies to lovers, or solving mysteries will enjoy this book. If you have read Maniscalco’s Stalking Jack the Ripper, Tracy Deonn's Legendborn, or Shea Ernshaw's The Wicked Deep, you will enjoy this novel.

Maniscalco plans to publish a sequel to this book, Kingdom of the Cursed, which will be published in October of this year. 

Women's History Month - Recommended Reads

In honor of Women's History Month, the Winter Park Library's Teen Book Guild read multiple novels that represent women of various time periods, cultures, and ages. The stories chosen below do not only educate about different historical events; rather, they also allow readers to grasp how individuals might have felt in those times, bringing a more personal connection to those historical circumstances for readers. The humor, seriousness, strength, adventures, and persistence of these women will not disappoint.

Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys was NOT a good book. It was a GREAT book! Not only did it have courageous characters and a fascinating, climax-building plot, it also told an untold, almost forgotten part of history that everyone should know! I truly feel that it is our duty to remember all the courageous people that were murdered and persecuted by the Soviet Union. There is no better way to celebrate Women’s History Month then by reading this novel, an incredible story of a young girl experiencing some of the worst circumstances, but still overcoming!

In The Downstairs Girl by Stacey Lee Jo Kuan is a young Chinese girl in the late 1800s. Her and her adoptive father are one of the few Chinese citizens in Atlanta, as they live in a predominantly wealthy white neighborhood. To get by in life, she began working as a maid for one of the wealthiest men in town during the day, and after being mistreated by her employer, she decided to start a new column called Dear Miss Sweetie in her local newspaper to write about the serious issues that no one wants to talk about. Jo Kuan is a vibrant, courageous, and hardworking young woman who has a powerful message and story to share about women's leadership and perseverance through injustices and problems in our society, which is exactly what Women's History Month it’s all about.

 

Set in 1906, Jennifer Donnelly's A Northern Light tells the fictional story of Mattie Gokey, a young woman who aspires to become a writer. Even though those dreams seem impossible for Mattie to accomplish, she continues to use words as a way to learn, escape, and express herself. Additionally, Jennifer Donnelly’s novel weaves in the legitimate murder of Grace Brown, described through Mattie’s eyes. In reading Grace’s letters, Mattie discovers how to regain her voice and go after what she wants despite her fears. This book is a perfect read for Women’s History Month, providing the reader with a tale of history, mystery, and perseverance.

Julie Berry’s novel, The Passion of Dolssa, is a historical, religious,  and romance novel that takes place during Medieval Europe in the country of France. In 1241, Dolssa is a young and mature woman who is part of the upper class family that has a mysterious gift that was naturally given to her. Having a title as a non-believer, she flees from a friar condemned her mother to death by fire and wants Dolssa to face the same consequences. Botille, a marriage broker, has a difficult time keeping herself and her younger sisters safe in a small seaside town of Bajas. Botille runs into Dolssa as she is falling ill and hides her in a local shelter from the friar. Both Botille and Dolssa develop a close friendship when Botille brings Dolssa back to normal as Bajas is being attacked. The Passion of Dolssa is a wonderful read for Women's History Month as it shows that two young girls have each other and increases womanhood with friendship, love, and service.

Stacey Lee’s enchanting Under a Painted Sky centers on one of the lesser-known areas of American history--the stories of the Chinese immigrants in the 1800s and their descendants. In 1849 Missouri, Samantha Young suffers an unspeakable tragedy which turns into a crime that sends her racing for California with the help of a runaway slave named Annamae. While life on the Oregon Trail is rough, the two girls forge a powerful bond of friendship as they struggle to survive undetected and search for missing keys to their pasts-unfortunately, the law is closing in fast and they are running out of time and hiding places. This book is a gem in a minefield. A true tribute to Women's History Month, it is smart, adventurous, and a celebration of the strength of women.

Our take on Printz

 Written by Hope M., Lauren M., and Lisa W.

Each year, the American Library Association "honors the best best book written for teens, based entirely on its literary merit." Sometimes these books really resonate with teen readers (like Looking For Alaska) and other times they are head-scratchers that don't really appeal to your average teen. We take a look at this year's Printz winner and honor books and share our own thoughts on their merits.

2021 Winner
Everything Sad Is Untrue (A True Story) by Daniel Nayeri depicts the life of the author and narrator throughout his childhood. In one book, Nayeri weaves together a tale of facts and feelings, struggles and strength, fiction and nonfiction, and so much wisdom. While reading, I felt like the author was speaking directly to me. Furthermore, his personal questions and thoughts caused me to reflect in ways I haven't before. I was surprised by how much I enjoyed the novel. On a grading scale of A-F, Everything Sad Is Untrue (A True Story) gets an A+ from me!

-Hope

2021 Honor Books

Apple (Skin To The Core) by Eric Gansworth is a memoir depicting the author's life growing up in the Onodaga Tribe in America. Written in verse, Gansworth uses his experiences (and a few Beatles references) to empower Native Americans and help them embrace their identities. Honestly this book was slightly confusing, especially at the beginning; I've read many books written in verse before, however the format of each line had me wondering whether I was reading the book itself or a strange (and long) prologue. Nevertheless, I do feel as if the book allowed me to fully comprehend the horrors that most Native Americans had to endure. If I were to grade Gansworth's work, I would give it a B.

- Lisa

In Dragon Hoops, Gene Luen Yang's newest graphic novel, we dive deep into Bishop O'Dowd High School's basketball team as they make their way through the 2014-15 season with hopes of finally winning the State Championships. Striking and thought-provoking, Dragon Hoops introduces readers to the members of the team and explores the principles and mannerisms that make a winning team that go far deeper than drills and practice--principles the apply to every area of life. An A on the grading scale of A-F, Yang's latest will have readers cheering the Dragons on throughout. 

-Lauren

Every Body Looking by Candace Iloh portrays the life of Ada, a young woman who struggles to find her identity and take control of her own destiny. The novel goes back and forth between her present and her past, illustrating the difficult circumstances Ada has experienced from her childhood up to her life at college.Many mature themes are presented in the story, and the author's unique writing style allowed me to empathize with the character's trials. Despite this, I didn't really enjoy it. For this reason, I would give this book a D.

-Hope

We Are Not Free by Traci Chee World War II is a subject that is approached frequently by authors, however Traci Chee finds an innovative and enlightening way to utilize that topic to introduce another part of history that is, sadly, not as well known. We Are Not Free is a passionate and heart-wrenching story about 14 Japanese-American teenagers whose lives are uprooted when they are placed in incarceration camps during World War II. I recommend this book, not because it was an enjoyable read, but because the abuse and racism that Japanese-Americans had to face should not be an obscure part of history. The only negative comment that I have for We Are Not Free is that 14 different points-of-view are a bit difficult to tolerate, seeing as every time the reader begins to sympathize with the character, the POV is switched to someone else’s. Ergo, I wasn’t able to connect to any of them. I would give this book an A-.

-Lisa

Stalking Jack the Ripper by Kerri Maniscalco

Reviewed by Kana C.
Grade 11

Audrey Rose is not your typical 1800s woman. She was born into a life of wealth and privilege. But other than attending tea parties and other typical events that ladies do, Audrey studies the gruesome art of forensic medicine.

When a string of brutally murdered corpses continue to show up in her uncle’s lab, Audrey gets drawn into the investigation. As she follows the clues, they bring her closer to her sheltered world. Audrey Rose is the girl who loved Jack the Ripper.

This book was amazing, with so many twists that I never saw coming. Kerri Maniscalco really brought the story to life with her amazing and very descriptive writing. Once I got into the story I couldn’t put the book down. Stalking Jack the Ripper is not for the faint hearted, Kerri Maniscalco goes deep into her explanations of the dead bodies and the forensic medicine process.

If you like a girl determined to be pretty, smart, and fierce and a witty, sarcastic, caring British boy involved in one gruesome mystery, mixed with a little bit (ok maybe a lot) of secrets, then Stalking Jack the Ripper is perfect for you. Maybe you can figure out who Jack the Ripper is before Audrey can. This is the story of the girl who loved the Ripper.

Under a Painted Sky by Stacey Lee

Reviewed by Lauren M.
Grade 11

Stacey Lee’s Under a Painted Sky is an enchanting tale of daring and adventure in the Old West. Heartwarming, engaging, and amusing, it follows a young Chinese- American as she struggles for freedom and equality, and is a true tribute to the strength of women.

Samantha Young lives with her father in 1849 Missouri. After a horrific tragedy leads to a shocking crime, she bands together with a runaway slave named Annamae and they set out on the Oregon Trail for California. As they each search for the missing ties to their pasts, they find unexpected allies in a band of cowboys. But with bounty hunters and the law closing in, how long will they be able to keep up their lies?

I loved this book. The worldbuilding was as realistic and believable as the plot. I also found the story to be immersive and compelling, and even in parts challenging to society’s long-held beliefs about equality and race. Samantha was realistic--since she’s so young, she struggles through the usual teenage dramas albeit with unfortunate doses of danger and tragedy mingled in with them. Nevertheless, through it all she was strong and had the benefit of a supportive community, namely her friends. Said friends were also firmly developed, especially Annamae, who was as loyal as she was incredibly spirited. Although I would have liked to see/know more about the Old West, there was just enough information to keep the reader happy.

I would absolutely recommend this book. It is humorous, adventurous, and a very fun story. If anyone likes a historical western, this is definitely for them. A natural reading choice for Women’s History Month, Under a Painted Sky receives a 5 out of 5 star rating.

Counting Down With You by Tashie Bhuiyan

Reviewed by Lauren M.
Grade 11

In Tashie Bhuiyan’s upcoming novel Counting Down with You (to be released in May 2021), a teenage girl battles anxiety and severe familial expectations. Although the story itself was interesting and the plot had potential, I found it to be incohesive and simply too long.

Karina Ahmed is a sixteen year old Bangladeshi-Muslim American who is gravely afraid of disappointing her parents. Although she is proud to be a Muslim and embraces it, she believes her family is too conservative. When her parents fly to Bangladesh for a month, she is afforded a bit of freedom. But when she is roped into tutoring Ace Clyde (a boy with a questionable reputation), she begins to wonder if she is crossing too many lines--especially when they start pretending to date. But as she counts down the days until her parents’ return, a new thought grows more powerful in her heart: What does she want? Dare she even fight for it?

The story was interesting--it provided a chance to peek into a world and culture not portrayed in mainstream media. Likewise the plot held just enough to interest, but unfortunately, that flicker was all there was to it. Bhuiyan is a great writer, but she had Karina’s thoughts flying in all directions.

Chunks of text could have been cut out, and it would still be cohesive--more so, even. However, the biggest issue was neither the story nor the plot but the characters, specifically Karina. I appreciated the diversity, but I found myself disliking her--she seemed very rigid and even mean at times, especially to people who only showed her kindness, like Ace. While I understand that her family was extremely burdensome and her anxiety amplified her problems, that does not excuse much of her behavior. She often complained, told people they did not understand, and then had to be forced to communicate her grievances in a way that inspired change. Another thing I did not appreciate was the way her anxiety was written; it was not painted in a very educational or hopeful light and was not true to reality in many ways.

While promising, Counting Down with You disappointed me. It simply lacked the character development and action it needed. I would rate this as a two out of five stars.

Where the Rhythm Takes You by Sarah Dass

Reviewed by Anna M.
Grade 9

While Sarah Dass’s debut novel Where the Rhythm Takes You was not the best YA book I’ve read, it definitely was not the worst. It is a retelling of Jane Austen’s Persuasion, and if you’re looking for the similarities you can find many.

Taking place in Tobago, the novel began with Reyna, a seventeen-year-old girl trying to run her late mother’s hotel almost completely by herself. Then, like every other romance, her ex-boyfriend, Aiden, shows up with his bandmates and two women, one of which may or may not be his new girlfriend. Awkwardly, Reyna and Aiden decide to avoid each other, but since he’s staying at HER HOTEL…..well let’s just say that doesn’t happen. Aiden’s friends actually ask Reyna’s father for her to be their guide around Tobago. Her dad, who is completely ignorant of the romance once between Aiden and Reyna, agrees, wanting to give Reyna a fun vacation. By fate (or maybe just good luck), Aiden and Reyna are always thrown together, and Reyna finds herself falling in love again or maybe she just never stopped. Unselfishly, she is willing to sacrifice her dreams and happiness to live out her mom’s plans for her life. Worried about the hotel and her feelings with Aiden, Reyna feels the weight of the world on her shoulders.

Showing the experience of loss, love, and hope, this novel was definitely an interesting read. However, I found it hard to buy into the “never stopped loving you” fluff, especially since Aiden was hooking up with another girl during the time spent apart. Personally, I think if someone really loves somebody, they’re going to be loyal to that person, but everyone’s entitled to their own opinion I guess. Overall, I thought the novel was a pretty generic YA romance, though it was unique that the setting was in the Caribbean. The writing was well done; therefore the cheesiness of the romance was forgivable. Ultimately, I think Sarah Dass is a good author and I look forward to reading more novels by her.

While it has romance novel stereotypes, it also has an originality that’s hard to pinpoint. This book was not a bad time-killer. I would not recommend this book to someone who does not like romance, but if you do, give it a try.