Wednesday, January 19, 2022

Lulu and Milagro's Search For Clarity by Angela Velez

Reviewed by Anna M.
Grade 10

For me, this book got off to a rough start immediately. The second I saw the title: Lulu and Milagro’s Search for Clarity, I was not expecting it to turn out good. Personally, I don’t think a title should be the quick answer to a summary. I mean, if we wanted to just end this review, you might ask, “What’s this book about?” and I could just say, “Lulu and Milagro’s Search for Clarity.” That’d be the end; however, even with the irritating title, the novel wasn’t horrible.

The story begins with two girls who live in Baltimore with their single mother. Each sister has a goal they want to accomplish over spring break. Lulu, the youngest (and more mature), wants to go on her school’s cross-country college trip AND complete her interview for a summer internship program at Stanford, her dream school. Milagro, the middle sister, wants to do “it” for the first time with her jerk boyfriend, Pablo. Both girls face HUGE obstacles before they even get a chance to start. Their mom begins asking Lulu not to go away to Stanford for the summer. The oldest daughter, Clara, went off to college, and when she returned, she was an entirely different person. Mami and Clara now aren’t speaking. Mami doesn’t what happened with Clara to happen with her other two daughters. However, it’s Lulu’s dream to go to Stanford and work in conservation biology and staying in Baltimore could be sacrificing that dream forever. In order to get her mom to let her go and show her being away doesn’t change anything, Lulu must find a way to fix Clara and Mami’s relationship. While this is all going on, Milagro is being called in the principal’s office and as a result, finds out one of the honors students dropped out. Shockingly, Milagro, who’s not the D-minus student you’d expect her to be, is next in line.

Milagro, however, DOES NOT want to go. She simply has no interest in college and doesn’t see the point. Not to mention, it would wreck all her plans with Pablo. Her mother ends up forcing her. With no other choice but to go, Milagro invites Pablo over early. Nevertheless, before they do anything, she sees evidence of Pablo cheating on his phone. She breaks up with him and sends the punk on his way. Milagro must find a way to get over the breakup with her “perfect” boyfriend or find a way to get him back. The extremely opposite girls must accomplish completely opposite tasks with extremely opposite trials. However, on the journey, they might just find out they’re not that different after all and how important sisterhood will be throughout their lives.

Once you get past the title and the unbelievably aggravating boyfriend, the book isn’t terrible. It has a very important message of celebrating family differences AND the importance of sisterhood. However, even with the excellent messages, I couldn’t help but feel the coming-of-age/going-to-college storyline is a bit overdone. I also felt the story and actual author’s style was dumbed down.

In conclusion, this novel had many excellent morals, and I think it conveyed the coming-of-age storyline well. Still, if you’re looking for a book with quality and something you’ll remember for being an amazing book, you should pass. If you’re looking for just another stereotypical teenage novel, this is a good book for you. Angela Velez wasn’t a terrible writer, and I hope to see a little more creativity, growth, and substance in her next novel.


Monday, January 10, 2022

Layoverland by Gabby Noone


Reviewed by Anna M.
Grade 9

Layoverland by Gabby Noone SHOULD HAVE been a great book. It had all the characters: the spunky and opinionated, not-like other girls, Converse-wearing main-character; the quirky best friend/roommate who doesn’t seem to know what personal space is; and the adorably stupid love interest that’s not “supposed” to happen but always does. Not only did the novel have all the characters…it also had an interesting plot as well. However, there is a reason why I wrote “SHOULD HAVE” at the beginning because even with all the story development…it was still just an incredibly “meh” book.

While most YA books begin with a teen’s life, this one began with death, the death of a seventeen-year-old girl named Beatrice Fox. After a huge argument with her younger sister, Bea dies in a car accident on December 12, 2019, 9:19 p.m., at the intersection of Huntingdon Pike and Susquehanna Road, Northwood, Pennsylvania. The big plot twist is even with her life being ended; her journey has really just begun. Bea doesn’t go to heaven, but she doesn’t go to hell either; instead, she goes to “the airport.” In this fictional world Noone created, good people go to heaven. Bad people go to hell. And in-between people go to the airport. The airport is where the in-between people watch their lives through a “memstractor” in order to find the reason they’re being kept out of heaven. Once they have a realization and a redemptive moment, they get to move on to heaven. Since Bea was such an unkind person on Earth, her punishment is to help 5,000 souls decipher through the “memstractor” why they’re being kept out of heaven. When she does this, she gets to move on herself. However, when she has to help Caleb Smith, her very own murderer, get to heaven, she decides to do whatever she can to make him suffer and keep him out of heaven. Though as she gets to know Caleb, she realizes he’s actually a really nice guy…and on top of that…begins to fall for him.

Sounds like a great book, right? Wrong. Very, very wrong. Layoverland was just boring, and I didn’t really find myself rooting or even sympathizing with ANY of the characters. All of them were really entitled and spoiled. Even though the plot was unique, reading this book just felt like reading any other teen drama/romance. Not to mention, Noone put many stereotypes in it, not trying to dismantle them in any way. I wouldn’t say it’s the worst book I’ve ever read, but I’d definitely say it’s exactly like ever other bad one I’ve read. It’s simply not special.

In conclusion, I would absolutely NOT recommend this book. I’m not trying to down the author or even the people who probably liked this story…that’s your own personal opinion. However, if you’re looking for a good book to read, keep looking! This is not the book for you!